Australia’s eSafety commissioner has imposed a significant fine on X, the social media platform previously known as Twitter, amounting to 610,500 Australian dollars (equivalent to over $380,000 U.S.). The fine was levied due to X’s failure to adequately disclose information pertaining to its efforts in combating child abuse content. While X has publicly asserted that addressing child sexual exploitation holds paramount importance, this recent fine underscores the urgent need for tangible action in upholding this commitment.
Empty Talk and Insufficient Action
Commissioner Julie Inman Grant emphasized the necessity of substantiating words with concrete measures, stating, “It can’t just be empty talk; we need to see words backed up with tangible action.” The commissioner’s remarks highlight the widening gap between the company’s claims and its actual practices. This penalty, although relatively small in terms of X’s financial resources, contributes to the mounting criticism leveled against the tech giant since its acquisition and rebranding by Elon Musk.
The fine was imposed under Australia’s Online Safety Act, introduced in 2021, which requires online service providers to disclose their strategies for combatting child abuse content. Failure to comply with this reporting obligation can result in civil penalties. X, as well as other major tech companies like Google, TikTok, Twitch, and Discord, received legal notices from Australia’s eSafety office in February. These notices posed specific queries regarding how these companies handle instances of child exploitation content. However, X’s response was characterized by numerous unanswered questions and incomplete sections, making their lack of transparency glaring.
X was not singled out by the eSafety office; other tech giants also faced scrutiny for their handling of child abuse content. The office expressed significant reservations about the policing methods on the five platforms it sent legal notices to, citing “serious shortfalls.” Google, in particular, received a formal warning for providing generic responses rather than addressing specific concerns.
The eSafety commissioner determined that X’s failure to meet Australia’s reporting standards was particularly egregious, leading to the imposition of a formal fine. For example, X did not provide crucial information concerning its response time to child abuse reports, the techniques it employs to identify instances of child sexual exploitation, and the number of employees dedicated to safety and public policy roles. The lack of disclosure in these areas indicates a troubling disregard for fundamental reporting and accountability standards.
The Alarming Disparity in Commitment
Internal records obtained by NBC News and CNBC in December 2022 revealed that out of approximately 1,600 staff members at X, only around 25 held titles associated with “Trust and Safety.” This stark disproportion illustrates a glaring gap between the company’s stated commitment to addressing child abuse content and the actual allocation of resources towards fulfilling this promise.
Australia’s eSafety commissioner’s fine on X brings to the forefront the repercussions of insufficient transparency and lack of action concerning child abuse content. With the imposition of penalties and warnings, tech giants must recognize the urgency of concrete measures to combat this pervasive issue. It is imperative that companies like X promptly address these concerns, demonstrate a genuine commitment to protecting vulnerable individuals, and provide the necessary resources to effectively police their platforms.